Dumbing Down the Textbooks... Students' Reading Choices
Below are interesting
studies on two obstacles on the path to college-level reading:
1. The dumbing down of text books and the related drop in SAT
verbal scores; and
2. The failure of independent reading programs to budge reading
comprehension scores.
Read on to see how the boosting your word power with TargetScore! Vocabulary can help increase your reading comprehension skills. can help
solve both problems.
How can TargetScore! Vocabulary help improve reading speed and
comprehension, while creating lifelong readers? One way is by giving
students challenging texts; texts at their vocabulary learning
zone that neither frustrate nor bore them;
texts that aren't dumbed down!
1. SCHOOLBOOK SIMPLIFICATION
(American Educational Research Journal, Summer,1996 No. 2,
pp 489-508, Donald P. Hayes, L.T. Wolfer and M. F. Wolfe) described changes in
the LEX levels of American and British schoolbooks used in pre-primary through
college level courses.
The analyses
showed the extent of simplification in every grade, from primers on. Simplification of schoolbooks had occurred after
the American Civil War and again after WW I. The post WW II simplification
began in the late 1940s and continued through the
1950s–reducing student access to the depth or breadth of domain knowledge. Substantively, this paper links the nationwide use
of simplified texts to the huge decline in mean verbal SAT and ACT scores which
began in 1963 and continued declining in each of the next 16 years. In the
quarter-century since, schools have tried many means to raise verbal scores,
but SAT and NAEP testing fails to find any increase -- whereas mathematics
scores have risen modestly. The one thing publishers and educators
have not done is raise modern textbook LEXile to its former level in every grade.
2. STUDENTS CHOOSE THE WRONG BOOKS.
Studies show that sustained silent reading does not help
reading comprehension (see Voice of Evidence: Shanahan chapter, Edit. McCardle
& Chabra, Brookes, 2004). How can that be, you ask, when some schools
dedicate 90+ hours a year to schoolwide reading?
The more you read the better
you read, right? Wrong. Because students choose the wrong texts: good readers
choose easy text so they can relax. Struggling readers choose texts that are too
difficult (afraid of appearing dumb) and
then pretend to read for 90 hours a year! To get the right kind of reading
comprehension practice, adults must guide students to readings at the right
level-of-difficulty.
(Cont.')